Skip to main navigation menu Skip to main content Skip to site footer
logo czasopisma

Articles

No. 2 (36) (2021)

Reception, as milestone for creation of legal system (on the example of Corporate Law of post-Soviet Georgia)

DOI
https://doi.org/10.36128/priw.vi36.284
Submitted
April 19, 2021
Published
2021-07-21

Abstract

The author reviews the transformation of Corporate Law on the example of post-Soviet Georgia. The reception which shapes the legal system, in transformative society comprises a considerably lengthy period. Frequent and unsystematic amendments of legislation in the post-communist community cause instability and nihilism, which is the main hindering factor for the corporate economy. The author examines the stages of Transition Law development, the conception of voluntary and compulsory reception,
a transformation of law as a cultural phenomenon, the role of Comparative Law, and the impact of EU supranational Corporate Law on the formation of contemporary Georgian
Law. The author presents the gaps of the current Corporate Law, also the dilemma between the models of regulation and deregulation, and he outlines the inevitable necessity
of modernization of the field.

References

  1. Ajani Gianmaria, ,,By Chance and Prestige: Legal Transplants in Russia and Eastern Europe”, Am. J. Comp. L., Vol. 43, No. 1, (1995): 93-117.
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  2. Allen William T., Kraakman Reinier, Subramanian Guhan, Commentaries and Cases on the Law of Business Organization, 3. Edit., (Wolters Kluwer, Aspen Publishers, 2009).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  3. Arlt Marie-Agnes in: AktG Kommentar, Hrsg. Wulf Goette, Mathias Habersack, Susanne Kalss, 5 Auf., (München: C. H. Beck, 2019).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  4. Basedow Jürgen, ,,Georgien und die Europäisierung des Privatrechts” [in:] Transformation durch Rezeption?, Hrsg. Eugenia Kurzynsky-Singer, (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck 2014).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  5. Bregvadze Lasha, “Legal culture between globalism and localism: for functional definition of legal transfers”, Herald of the T. Tsereteli State and Law Institute, no. 1, (2006): 5-37 (In Georgian).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  6. Bungert Hartwin, Gesellschaftsrecht in den USA, 3. Aufl., (München: Rehm, 2003).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  7. Burduli Irakli, ,,Das georgische Gesellschaftsrecht: Quo Vadis?! Eine kurze Darstellung der Reformen und des Refrombedarfs im georgischen Unternehmensrecht” [in:] Rechtsvergleichung und Privatrecht im deutsch-georgischen Diskurs, Hrsg. Tiziana J. Chiusi, Irakli Burduli, Band 14, (Saarbrücken: Jurisprudentia Saraviensis, Alma Mater, 2019), 1-25.
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  8. Burduli Irakli, ,,Nekrorezeption in Transformationsgesellschaften” [in:] Dogmatik im Dienst von Gerechtigkeit, Rechtssicherheit und Rechtsentwicklung, Festschrift für Hans Prütting zum 70, Hrsg. Moritz Brinkmann, Barbara Völzmann-Stickelbrock, Daniel Oliver Effer-Uhe, Sabine Wesser, Stephan Weth, (Köln: Carl Heymanns, 2018), 3-15.
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  9. Burduli Irakli, Makharoblishvili Giorgi, Egnatashvili Demetre, Ebanoidze Giorgi, Capital Market’s capacity to function: existing reality and necessity of reform, (Tbilisi: Lawyers’ World, 2017).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  10. Burduli Irakli, Basics of Corporate Law, Volume II, (Tbilisi: Meridiani, 2013) (In Georgian).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  11. Burduli Irakli, Basics of Corporate Law, Volume I (Tbilisi: Meridiani, 2010), 391 (In Georgian).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  12. Burduli Irakli “Statutory Capital and its functions” [in:] Theoretical and practical issues of modern corporate law, edit. Gia Liluashvili, (Tbilisi: Meridiani, 2009) 208-262 (In Georgian).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  13. Burduli Irakli, Development of Corporate (Trade) law in Georgian and Germany, (Tbilisi: Tobalis, 2007) (In Georgian).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  14. Casper Matthias, ,,Sharia Boards and Corporate Governance“ [in:] Festschrift für Klaus J. Hopt, zum 70, Hrsg. Stefan Grundmann, Brigitte Haar, Hanno Merkt & et al. (Berlin:De Gruyter, August 2010), 446-477.
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  15. Chanturia Lado, Main directions of the reform of law “on Entrepreneurs” [in:] Historical profiles of legal and political thinking, Book III, (Tbilisi: Meridiani, 2015) (In Georgian).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  16. Chanturia Lado, ,,Voraussetzungen einer erfolgreichen juristischen Zusammenarbeit aus der Sicht der Transformationsgesellschaften“, [in:] Rechtstransfer und internationale rechtliche Zusammenarbeit, Deutsche und Japanische Erfahrungen bei der Kooperation mit Osteuropa und Zentralasien, Hrsg. Herbert Küpper, Wolfgang Brenn, (Wien: Peter Lang, 2010).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  17. Chanturia Lado, Corporate Governance and Responsibilities of Managers in the Corporate Law, (Tbilisi: Law, 2006) (In Georgian).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  18. Chanturia Lado, “Statutory autonomy in the Corporate Law”, [in:] Profiles of history of legal and political thinking, edit. Gocha Feradze, Book I, (Tbilisi: Meridiani, 2010) (In Georgian).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  19. Chanturia Lado, ,,Die Europäisierung des Georgischen Rechts – Blosser Wunsch oder grosse Herausforderung?” RabelsZ, I 74 (2010): 154-181.
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  20. Chanturia Lado, ,,Chancen und Schatten des Self-Enforcing-Modells im postsowjetischen Aktienrecht”, no.4, WiRO, (2009): 97-103.
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  21. Chanturia Lado, ,,Das neue Zivilgesetzbuch Georgiens: Verhältnis zum deutschen Bürgerlichen Gesetzbuch” [in]: Aufbruch nach Europa – 75 Jahre nach Max-Plank Institut für Privatrecht, Hrsg. Jürgen Basedow, Ulrich Drobnig, Reinhard Ellger, Klaus J. Hopt Hein Kötz, Rainer Kulms, Ernst-Joachim Mestmäcker, (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2001).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  22. Chanturia Lado “Law on Entrepreneurs and formation of the Corporate law”, [in:] Anniversary Collection of Sergo Jorbenadze, (Tbilisi: Law, 1996) (in Georgian).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  23. Charles H. Fairbanks, ,,Georgia’s Rose Revolution”, Journal of Democracy, vol. 15, no. 2 (2004): 110-124.
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  24. Dauner-Lieb Barbara in: Martin Henssler, Lutz Strohn (Hrsg.) AktG Kommentar, 5. Auf., (München: C. H. Beck 2021).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  25. Dobó László, Kuijpers Lambert, ,,Countries with Economies in Transition” [in:] Protecting the Ozone Layer. Eds. Philippe G. Le Prestre, John D. Reid, Thomas E. Morehouse (New York: Springer, 1998).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  26. Ewald William, ,,Comparative Jurisprudence (II)”, Am. J. Comp. L., Vol. 43, No. 4 (1995): 489-510.
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  27. Fleischer Holger, ,,Legal Transplants im deutschen Aktienrecht”, NZG, 24 (2004): 1129–1137.
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  28. Häberle Peter, ,,Theorieelemente eines allgemeinen juristischen Rezeptionsmodells“, JZ , 47. Jahrg., Nr. 21, (1992): 1033 – 1043.
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  29. Häberle Peter, Europäische Rechtskultur, (Baden-Baden: Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft, 1994).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  30. Japaridze Sergi, Trade Law, (Tbilisi: Publishing House Kordzadze, 2019) (In Georgian).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  31. Jibuti Nino, “Interview with professor Pastrich”, [in:] Review of private law, no. 1, (2015): 138-142, (In Georgian).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  32. Jorbenadze Sandro, “Main problems of future Civil Code of the Republic of Georgia”, [in:] Law reform in Georgia, eds. Sandro Jorbenadze, Sandro Jorbenadze, Rolf Knieper, Lato Chanturia (Tbilisi: 1994) (In Georgian).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  33. Jugheli Giorgi, Protecting capital in the Joint Stock company, (Tbilisi: Siesta, 2010) (In Georgian).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  34. Kandelaki Giorgi, ,,Georgia’s Rose Revolution. A Participant’s Perspective”, US Institute of Peace, Jul. 1, (2006), 1-12, www.jstor.org/stable/resrep12267 [accessed:15.03.21.].
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  35. Kekelia Mikheil, Crimes against human life, health, honor and dignity in the ancient Georgian law, (Tbilisi: Meridiani, 2015) (In Georgian).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  36. Khamidov Khalifabobo, ,,Die Rechtsreform in der Republick Tadschikistan” [in:] Wege zu neuem Recht, Hrsg. Mark Boguslavski, Rolf Knieper, (Berlin: Arno Spitz, 1998).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  37. Kindl Johann, Gesellschaftsrecht, 2. Auf., (Baden-Baden: Nomos, 2019).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  38. Koch Jens [in:] Uwe Hüffer, Jens Koch, AktG Kommentar, 15 Auf., (München: C. H. Beck, 2021).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  39. Knieper Rolf, Chanturia Lado, Schramm Hans-Joachim, Das Privatrecht im Kaukasus und Zentralasien. Bestandsaufnahme und Entwicklung, (Berlin: BWV, 2010).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  40. Knieper Rolf, Rechtsreformen entlang der Seidenstrasse. Aufsätze und Vorträge während der beobachtenden Teilnahme an einem gewaltigen Transformationsprozess, (Berlin: BWV, 2006).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  41. Knieper Rolf, Juristische Zusammenarbeit: Universalität und Kontext, (Wiesbaden: Universumverlag, 2004).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  42. Knieper Rolf, ,,Das neue Turkmenische Zivilgesetzbuch im Überblick”, WiRO, no.2 (2002): 53-55.
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  43. Khubua Gia, “Institutional balance of power” [in:] The Constitution of Georgia after 20 years, (Tbilisi: Open Society Georgia Foundation, 2016): 103-117 (In Georgian).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  44. Kurzynsky-Singer Eugenia, ,,Wirkungsweise der legal transplants bei den Reformen des Zivilrechts” [in:] Transformation durch Rezeption?, Hrsg. Eugenia Kurzynsky-Singer, (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2014).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  45. Lazarashvili Lali, “Law of Georgia on “Entrepreneurs” and problems of modern legislative regulation of the Georgian corporate law” [in:] Besarion Zoidze Anniversary Collection, eds. Lado Chanturia, Irakli Burduli (Tbilisi: TSU Publishing House, 2014), 521-537 (In Georgian).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  46. Legrand Pierre, ,,The Impossibility of Legal Transplants”, MJECL, vol. 4, (1997): 111-142.
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  47. Mattei Ugo, ,,Efficiency in Legal Transplants: An Essay in Comparative Law and Economics“, IRLE, vol. 14(1), (1994): 3-19.
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  48. Milhaupt Curtis J., Kanda Hideki, ,,Re-examining Legal Transplants: The Director’s Fiduciary Duty in Japanese Corporate Law”, Am. J. Comp. L., Vol. 51, No. 4, (2003): 887-901.
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  49. Mögelin Chris, Die Transformation von Unrechtsstaaten in demokratische Rechtsstaaten. Rechtlicher und politischer Wandel in Mittel- und Osteuropa am Beispiel Russlands, (Berlin: Duncker & Humbolt, 2003).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  50. Неру Джавахарлал, Открытие Индии. Пер. с англ, Кн. 2 (Москва: Политиздат, 1989).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  51. Nehru Jawaharlal, The Discovery of India, Jawaharlal Nehru Memorial Fund, (Oxford: Oxfrod University Press, 1982).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  52. Neubürger Heinz-Joachim, ,,Die deutsche Mitbestimmung aus der Sicht eines international operierenden Unternehmens. Reformbedarf unter Corporate Governance Gesichtspunkten?” [in:] Hdb Corporate Governance, Hrsg. Peter Hommelhoff, Klaus J. Hopt, Axel v. Werder, 1. Aufl. (Köln: Verlag Dr. Otto Schmidt, 2003).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  53. Papava Vladimer, Economy of Georgia, Reforms and pseudo reforms, (Tbilisi: Intellect, 2015) (In Georgian).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  54. Rabel Ernst, ,,Interationale Zusammenarbeit im Privatrecht, RabelsZ, 18. Jahrg., H. 4 (1953): 602-607, https://www.jstor.org/stable/27873230?seq=1 [accessed 13.03.2021].
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  55. Raiser Thomas, Rüdiger Veil, Recht der Kapitalgesellschaft, (München: Verlag Vahlen, 2010).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  56. Schalast Christoph, ,,Rechtsberatung und Rechtsstaat in Transformationsstaaten”, WiRO, (2005): 321-325.
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  57. Schwartz Herman, Establishing constitutional justice in the post-communistic Europe, Translator Ketevan Aleksidze (Tbilisi; Sezani, 2003) (In Georgian).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  58. Shevardnadze Eduard, Thoughts on Past and Future, Memoirs, (Tbilisi: Palitra L, 2006) (In Georgian).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  59. Sommermann Karl-Peter, ,,Deutsch-georgische wissenschaftliche Zusammenarbeit – Ein Erfahrungsbericht am Beispiel der Einrichtung eines Master-Studiengangs “public administration” an der Staatlichen Universität Tiflis” [in:] Grenzüberschreitende Entwicklungszusammenarbeit, Hrsg. Laure Ognois, Nr. 2012 (Speyer: Speyerer Arbeitsheft, 2013).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  60. Stalev Stozan, ,,Transformation des Rechts- und Wirtschaftsordnung in Bulgarien – Probleme und Perspektiven”, ZeuP, (1996): 444-451.
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  61. Суханов Евгений Алексеевич, ,,Проблемы Корпоративных Отношений в Проекте Новой Редакции Гражданского Кодекса Российской Федераций” [in:] Гражданское Право и Корпоративние Отнашения, (Москва: Изд. Алмати, 2013).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  62. Суханов Евгений Алексеевич, Сравнительное корпоративное право, (Москва: Изд. Статут, 2015).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  63. Surguladze Nugzar, “Persian Sources of the history of Georgian law (“Dastur Al-Muluq”, “Tazqirat Al-Muluq”)”, 1/2006, Herald of the T. Tsereteli State and Law Institute, (2006) (In Georgian).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  64. Vetter Eberhard, in: Reinhard Marsch-Barner, Frank A. Schäfer (Hrsg.), Hdb börsennotierte AG, 2. Auf., (Köln: Verlag Dr. O. Schmidt, 2009).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  65. Winter Gerd, Kalichava Koba, ,,Rechtstransfer und Eigendynamik in Transformationsländer: Das Beispiel der verwaltungsrechtsentwicklung in Georgien”, ZaöRV, 2 (2019): 273-324, https://www.zaoerv.de/79_2019/79_2019_2_a_273_324.pdf, [accessed 13.03.2021].
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  66. Zoidze Besarion, Attempt of getting to know practical existence of the law. Mostly in light of human rights, (Tbilisi: Publishing House of Tbilisi State University, 2013) (In Georgian).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  67. Zoidze Besarion, Reception of European Private Law in Georgia, (Tbilisi: Teaching Center for Publishing, 2005), (in Georgian).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  68. Zubitashvili Nona, Responsibility of partner for obligations of the corporation during insolvency of the society – exception from the principle of restriction of responsibility, Dissertation (Tbilisi: Publishing House of the Tbilisi state university, 2016) (In Georgian).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  69. Zweigert Konrad, Kötz Hein, Einführung in die Rechtsvergleichung, 3. Auf., (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 1996).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  70. Decision of the Supreme Court of Georgia #ას-1158-1104-2014.
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  71. Decision of the Supreme Court of Georgia #ას-1307-1245-2014.
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  72. (Kamin vs. American Express Co. 54 A.D.2d 654 (N.Y. 1976)).
    Show in Google Scholar -->>
  73. Explanatory note on the draft law of the law “on Entrepreneurs” https://matsne.gov.ge/ka/document/view/4962987?fbclid=IwAR3HYFK5dWlF6vpxHx3ZWNIx_FqMzC3nBWAKTBNKTFY-IIgshLNeMm4agqA&publication=0, [accessed:12.03.2021].
    Show in Google Scholar -->>

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.