Przejdź do głównego menu Przejdź do sekcji głównej Przejdź do stopki
Prawo i Więź

Artykuły

Tom 53 Nr 6 (2024): Prawo i Więź Nr 6 (53) 2024

The Rule of Law Principle in the Customs Law of Ukraine and the European Union. A Comparative Analysis

DOI
https://doi.org/10.36128/PRIW.VI53.914
Przesłane
16 kwietnia 2024
Opublikowane
21.03.2025 — zaktualizowane 30.03.2025
Wersje

Abstrakt

The paper’s goal is to present a proposal for discussion that would update the methods used in Ukrainian customs law science to interpret the meaning and relationship between legality and rule of law, as well as determine how these approaches fit into the operations of the country’s customs authorities. The paper’s goal required the use of a number of scientific cognition methods, such as historical and legal method; dialectical method; comparative method; systemic and structural method; hermeneutical method; method of analysis; method of synthesis; method of generalization, etc. The rule of law is highly valued in Ukrainian laws, law enforcement processes, and legal doctrine. However, its legal regulation in Ukrainian legislation and doctrinal legal analysis of its content and correlation with other principles of law, in particular the principle of legality, are carried out from the standpoint of legal positivism without taking into account the principles of the natural law concept of law understanding. The absence of a systematic approach to the normative and legal consolidation of the principle of the rule of law in the legislation of Ukraine led to the emergence of various options for a formal definition of its content, which significantly complicated its real knowledge. In view of the above, it is recommended to focus on developing a coherent approach to the interpretation of the content and correlation of the principles of legality and the rule of law, taking into account the principles of the natural law concept of law understanding, according to which they are correlated as part and parcel.

Bibliografia

  1. Bytyak Yu., V. Harashchuk, O. Dyachenko O. T. Zima, V. V. Zuy, I. M. Kompaniets, V. Ya. Nastyuk et al., Administrative Law of Ukraine. Kyiv: Yurinkom Inter, 2007.
  2. Evers Frank, OSCE Efforts to Promote the Rule of Law. Hamburg: CORE Centre for OSCE Research, 2010. https://www.files.ethz.ch/isn/141708/CORE_Working_Paper_20.pdf.
  3. Gorobets Konstantyn, „The Rule of Law as a Value-Normative Phenomenon” Philosophy of Law and General Theory of Law, 2 (2013): 207-213.
  4. Holovatyi Serhij, „The Rule of Law Does Not Work” Law of Ukraine, 11 (2019): 39-82.
  5. Holovatyi Serhij, The Rule of Law: Idea, Doctrine, Principle: Thesis Dissertation of Doctor of Law. Kyiv: Legislation Institute of The Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine, 2008.
  6. Holovatyi Serhij, O. F. Andriyko, V. P. Nagrebelny, L. Ye. Kysil, Yu. S. Pedko, V. A. Derets, A. A. Pukhtetska, A. V. Kirmach, „The Rule of Law Principle: Problems of Interpretation and Application in Administrative Law” Almanac of Law, 3 (2012): 77-82.
  7. Holovatyi Serhij, Rule of Law. Kyiv: Fenix, 2006.
  8. Horodovenko V., „Implementation of the Rule of Law Principle in Civil Proceedings in the Context of Justice Reform” Law of Ukraine, 3 (2018): 65-78.
  9. Ivanov S., „Principles of State Customs Policy in Ukraine: Concepts, Content and Classification Criteria.” Entrepreneurship, Economy and Law, 10 (2018): 179-185.
  10. Karska Elżbieta, Karol Karski, „Introduction: Extraterritorial Scope of Human Rights” International Community Law Review, No. 4-5 (2015): 395-401.
  11. Karska Elżbieta, Karol Karski, „Judicial Dialogue in Human Rights: Introductory Remarks” International Community Law Review, No. 5 (2019): 391-399.
  12. Karski Karol, Bartosz Ziemblicki, „Commercial Companies as Applicants before the European Court of Human Rights” International Community Law Review, No. 5 (2021): 503-525.
  13. Kolpakov V. K., Ye. V. Kurinniy, A. A. Sharaya, „Implementation of the Rule of Law Principle in Administrative Proceedings through the Prism of Applying the Judge's Discretion” Legal Scientific Electronic Journal, 2 (2022): 202-208.
  14. Komzyuk V. T., „Concepts and Types of Principles of Activity of Customs Authorities” Law and Society, 6 (2013): 198-202.
  15. Kuchuk A. M., „The Rule of Law as an Axiological Component of the National System of Law” Legal Scientific Electronic Journal, 3 (2023): 566-569.
  16. Kvashin V. Yu., „To the Description of the Principles of Ensuring the Rights of Citizens by the Customs Authorities of Ukraine” Scientific Bulletin of Public and Private Law, No. 1 (2019): 194-199.
  17. Lautenbach Geranne, The Concept of the Rule of Law and the European Court of Human Rights. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2013.
  18. Lemekha R. I., „Theoretical and Methodological Principles of Customs Regimes in Ukraine” Law and Society, 5 (2020): 76-83.
  19. Mushenok V. V., V. O. Timashov, „Legal Institute of Customs Control, Its Principles, Types” Private and Public Law, 2 (2020): 102-107.
  20. Oliinyk O. S., „Principles of Criminal Law in the World of ECHR Practice” Law and Society, 4 (2019): 254-260.
  21. Ostapenko O. I., M. V. Kovaliv, S. S. Yesimov, L. S. Hulak, H. Yu. Lukianova, O. V. Nikanorova, M. S. Tsvok, Administrative Law of Ukraine (General Part). Lviv: SPOLOM, 2021.
  22. Perepolkin S. M., A. V. Mazur, O. O. Marchenko, O. V. Morozov, I. V. Yefimova, „Sui Generis of European Union Customs Law” World Customs Journal, No. 2 (2022): 35-55.
  23. Shapoval T. B., „Concepts, Types, and Principles of Proceedings in Cases of Administrative Offense” Legal Scientific Electronic Journal, 8 (2022): 368-370.
  24. Tertyshnyk V. M., The Rule of Law and Ensuring the Establishment of Truth in the Criminal Process of Ukraine. Dnipro: Lira LTD, 2009.
  25. Tkachuk O., D. Luspenik, „The Rule of Law Is the New ‘Old’ Principle of Civil Proceedings: Correlation with the Principle of Legality” Word of the National School of Judges of Ukraine, No. 20 (2017): 50-66.
  26. Yaroshenko, O. M., O. Ye. Lutsenko, N. M. Vapnyarchuk, „Salary Optimisation in Ukraine in the Context of the Economy Europeanisation” Journal of the National Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine, No. 3 (2021): 224-237.
  27. Yaroshenko O. M., O. V. Moskalenko, L. Y. Velychko, V. S. Kovrygin, „Property Civil Law Liability and Material Liability of Employees for Damage Caused to an Employer: On the Basis of Civil Law of Ukraine” Asia Life Sciences, No. 2 (2019): 735-748.

Pobrania

Brak dostępnych danych do wyświetlenia.